Close Menu
The Daily Hoosier
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    Trending
    • “I was dead wrong about Indiana” — national pundits rethinking the Hoosiers
    • IU basketball recruiting: Hoosiers offer 2027 4-star forward Jeremy Jenkins
    • IU football’s Curt Cignetti shows respect for Iowa: ‘More difficult challenge than the last one’
    • Fernando Mendoza wins co-Big Ten Offensive POTW, other honors, after dissecting Illinois
    • Watch: IU football coach Curt Cignetti Monday Q&A — Iowa week
    • IU football week 5: Early odds, projections, notes, gameday details for road trip to Iowa
    • IU football: Snap counts and PFF grades of note from win over Illinois
    • Rankings update: Indiana rises in polls after dismantling Illinois
    • Sign Up
    • About/Support
    • Jobs
    • Tickets
      • IUBB Tickets (Stubhub)
      • IUFB Tickets (Stubhub)
    • Shop
      • Official IU Store
      • IU Adidas Store
      • Amazon: Support TDH
      • IU Memorabilia
      • IU Press (Books)
      • The Daily Hoosier T-Shirt
    • Radio/Podcasts
      • East 17th Street
    • Pro IU
      • IUBB NBA
      • IUFB NFL
      • IUBASE MLB
    • Hoosier History
      • Basketball History
      • March Madness Classics
      • Football History
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram YouTube
    The Daily HoosierThe Daily Hoosier
    Tuesday, September 23
    • IU Basketball
      • Latest IU Basketball News
      • 2025-26 IU Basketball Roster
      • IU Basketball 2025-26 Schedule
      • DeVries’ new staff
      • Future Schedules
      • Scholarship Chart
      • Big Ten Coming and Going
      • 2024-25 Big Ten Standings
      • 24-25 IU Basketball Stats
      • Rankings & Bracketology
      • IU Basketball Media Guide
    • IU Football
      • Latest IU Football News
      • 2025 Schedule
      • Current roster
      • 2025 IUFB Stats
      • 2025 B1G Standings
      • 2025 scholarship tracker
      • Future opponents through 2032
      • IU Football 2025 Record Book
    • IU Recruiting
      • IU Basketball Recruiting News
      • IU Football Recruiting News
      • IUBB 2026-28 Prospects
      • Recruit Interviews
      • Recruit Highlights
      • IU Football Recruiting Commits
    • IU Women’s Basketball
      • IU Women’s Basketball News
      • 24-25 Schedule
      • Big Ten Standings
    • IU Men’s Soccer
      • 2024 Schedule
      • Indiana Men’s Soccer: Program History
    • More Hoosiers
      • Fan and Business NIL options
      • IU Baseball
        • Baseball Schedule
        • Statistics
        • Big Ten Standings
      • IU Swim & Dive
      • IU Olympic Results
    • Community
      • Join our Discord Server!
    The Daily Hoosier

    “I was dead wrong about Indiana” — national pundits rethinking the Hoosiers

    TDH StaffBy TDH StaffSeptember 23, 2025 IU Football 5 Comments
    Photo by Seth Tow for TDH
    Share
    Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email

    The question was raised ad nauseum throughout the offseason:  Who is this year’s Indiana?

    Why not Indiana?

    With a 63-10 win over former No. 9 Illinois, IU has put themselves back in the national conversation for the College Football Playoff, and their quarterback Fernando Mendoza is one of the favorites to win the Heisman Trophy.

    And some of their biggest skeptics are finally waking up to this possibility:  Curt Cignetti and the Indiana Hoosiers just might be here to stay.

    And how could you doubt that at this point?

    In front of the second-largest crowd in program history (56,088), Indiana’s 63 points marked the most scored by a Big Ten team against an AP Top-10 opponent. And the 53-point margin of victory is the largest by a team outside the AP top-10 against an AP top-10 team — EVER.

    Since their CFP loss at Notre Dame last December, IU has been the constant subject of national skepticism, and at times even derision.

    But their performance on Saturday on a national stage against a top-10 team has the national pundits rethinking the Hoosiers.

    Here’s a sampling:

    ESPN’s KIRK HERBSTREIT AND JOEY GALLOWAY

    “Indiana ran through Illinois like they were division II school” – @Joey_Galloway 😂😂

    Impressive win for them#nonstop LIVE on YouTube! Come ask us some questions https://t.co/tx9LVJObMW pic.twitter.com/fMFkWZjUym

    — Kirk Herbstreit (@KirkHerbstreit) September 22, 2025

    FOX’s JOEL KLATT

    “What we saw Saturday night in Bloomington was ridiculous,” Klatt said. … “I thought Illinois would win this game and man, was I wrong. And I will be the first to raise my hand and tell you when I get something wrong. I was dead wrong about Indiana. I did not think that they could be better than they were a year ago. They are. They are.”

    ESPN’S PAT McAFEE

    “I thought it was going to be a tough game for Illinois, didn’t expect that.”

    (McAfee picked Indiana to beat Illinois on ESPN College Gameday)

    Indiana is STILL very good at football #PMSLive pic.twitter.com/yjfe20dY9n

    — Pat McAfee (@PatMcAfeeShow) September 22, 2025

    ESPN’S DAN WETZEL

    “What if Indiana actually employs the best coach, or at least the best for its situation, in college football? What if last season’s playoff run wasn’t some feel-good tale, but rather the start of bigger and bigger and bigger?”

    ESPN’S GREG McELROY

    “Indiana might be a national championship contender. Just let that soak in for a moment,” McElroy said.

    “Indiana is not a historical blue blood, not a team naturally in this conversation on an annual basis. I get all that. Even for me, it’s hard to come to this conclusion. I’ve seen Indiana lose a lot of games in my time as an analyst and as a fan of college football. But I’m telling you, this group feels different. They just dominated an Illinois team that I have some respect for.”

    ESPN’S RECE DAVIS:

    Google him. What a performance. Belt to rear End. And they aren’t done. @IndianaFootball pic.twitter.com/1R4E9tVcs2

    — Rece Davis (@ReceDavis) September 21, 2025

    CBS SPORTS’ TOM FORNELLI:

    Indiana is This Year’s Indiana, folks.

    — Tom Fornelli (@TomFornelli) September 21, 2025

    For complete coverage of IU football, GO HERE.


    The Daily Hoosier –“Where Indiana fans assemble when they’re not at Assembly”

    – Join our Premium Discord Chat by GOING HERE.

    • You can follow us on X: @daily_hoosier and find us on Facebook and Instagram 
    • Seven ways to support completely free IU coverage at no cost to you.

    Related

    Curt Cignetti IU Football
    TDH Staff

    Keep Reading

    IU football’s Curt Cignetti shows respect for Iowa: ‘More difficult challenge than the last one’

    Fernando Mendoza wins co-Big Ten Offensive POTW, other honors, after dissecting Illinois

    Watch: IU football coach Curt Cignetti Monday Q&A — Iowa week

    Latest Hoosier News
    • “I was dead wrong about Indiana” — national pundits rethinking the Hoosiers
    • IU basketball recruiting: Hoosiers offer 2027 4-star forward Jeremy Jenkins
    • IU football’s Curt Cignetti shows respect for Iowa: ‘More difficult challenge than the last one’
    • Fernando Mendoza wins co-Big Ten Offensive POTW, other honors, after dissecting Illinois
    • Watch: IU football coach Curt Cignetti Monday Q&A — Iowa week
    • IU football week 5: Early odds, projections, notes, gameday details for road trip to Iowa
    • IU football: Snap counts and PFF grades of note from win over Illinois
    Sign Up



    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram YouTube
    © 2025 The Daily Hoosier, LLC.

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.

    Ad Blocker Enabled!
    Ad Blocker Enabled!
    Our website is made possible by displaying online advertisements to our visitors. Please support us by disabling your Ad Blocker.