SEATTLE — After Washington football finished off a second touchdown drive near the end of the first quarter, Indiana head coach Curt Cignetti angrily directed his defense to gather around the bench area.
He held his headset in his hands as the Huskies kicked the extra point, and when the play finished, he immediately pointed to the bench and yelled at his players to go circle up. Cignetti watched the defense play one of its worst quarters of the season, allowing 192 yards of offense and 14 points.
And he made sure his defense knew it. He stomped on the ground, got in players’ faces, pointed his finger several times, and screamed at them. He knew that unit needed to play better for IU to have a chance to win.
It had all the makings of a classic Cignetti moment.
But this day — much like this season — felt different.
The Hoosiers have spent the 2026 season playing with fire, and Saturday in Seattle, they got burned. Washington fans stormed the field after a 27-24 upset victory.
“That’s a disappointing day,” Cignetti said after the game. “Our guys fought, in the second half, fought and clawed. But they made one more play than we did, and that’s that.”
There’s no clearer differentiator between Indiana’s 2025 and 2026 teams than that last sentence. The 2025 national champions enjoyed a lot of blowout wins, but in closer games, they ensured they would be the ones making the one extra play.
IU (9-2, 6-2 Big Ten) has needed that sort of magic earlier and more often this year than the 2025 group did, and there just wasn’t enough left.
“Every team’s identity is going to be different,” left tackle Carter Smith said. “I feel like the team this year, our identity is just, ‘Find a way.’ And I think we try our best to do that. Fell short today.”
The Hoosiers were haunted by a lot of their recurring issues from this season on Saturday.
They suffered more injuries, and have had to deal with that much more often than last year’s team did. 2025 Indiana rarely, if ever, had a sequence like it dealt with Saturday after right guard Adedamola Ajani left the game, which left the offensive line with three inexperienced players on the field.
Injuries and uncertainty mounting for IU football ahead of regular season finale
But that was far from the only problem. Cignetti, earlier in the week, made comments about not wanting to see another mobile quarterback run all over IU’s defense after it had trouble against Northwestern’s Aidan Chiles and Nebraska’s Anthony Colandrea.
The message didn’t land. Washington’s Demond Williams Jr. set the tone quickly with a 65-yard touchdown run on the game’s third play from scrimmage. He finished with 88 rushing yards on 11 attempts, which includes Indiana’s four sacks for -26 yards.
IU had kicking problems yet again, continuing Nico Radicic’s drastic regression. Washington (7-4, 4-4) blocked his 46-yard attempt early in the third quarter, which prompted Cignetti to turn to Paddy McAteer for any remaining placekicking duty. The Troy transfer made a 34-yard kick in the middle of the quarter, but missed from 37 yards in overtime, sealing the game for UW.
And Indiana’s offense endured the same sort of inconsistency that’s plagued the unit for more than half the season. The Hoosiers are dangerous and have ability to strike quickly, like they did on the 74-yard touchdown pass from Grant Wilson to Charlie Becker on their first play from scrimmage. But despite all the talent and all the threats on the field, IU’s offense just sputters for long stretches of game.
Wilson scored a rushing touchdown later in the first quarter, benefitting from strong field position. But outside of the two touchdowns and a kneel-down to end the first half, IU accumulated only 70 yards of offense across four possessions, ending in three punts and one turnover on downs. After Radicic’s miss, Cignetti opted to put Josh Hoover back at quarterback to spark the offense. And that did provide a jolt — Hoover looked as good as he has since he got banged up against Ohio State.
But it wasn’t enough. It’s difficult to get away with weaknesses in all three phases of the game, and that became an uphill battle for IU in Seattle.
Defensive end Stephen Daley acknowledged the mental toll of playing in close games every week, but knows that’s just part of football.
“I think it’s kind of why you play this sport, to be in moments like that, especially coming to Indiana for games like that, too. Just being in those (close games) kind of throughout the whole year — definitely a lot different than last year,” Daley said. “It’s still fun to be out there, just playing, having fun. Washington, their whole season has been close games too, so it was kind of foreseeable, I guess, a little bit.”
This result casts Indiana’s College Football Playoff chances in serious doubt.
The Hoosiers entered Saturday No. 8 in the CFP rankings, with the selection committee harping on their offensive inconsistency and perceived easier schedule compared to some other contenders. They’re not completely dead after suffering a second loss, but it’s entirely possible they’ll be outside the top 12 when the next rankings come out on Tuesday.
All IU can do is take care of business against Purdue and hope for help to reach the Big Ten Championship Game.
That’s part of why this will be a tough loss for Indiana to simmer in. This team, in spite of its critics, had everything in front of it — beat Washington and Purdue, and win in Indianapolis, and surely it’d get a top-four seed and first-round bye as a one-loss Big Ten champion. Now, the Hoosiers no longer control their own destiny.
Becker wore that reality on his face after the game, whether he’d admit it or not. He couldn’t compose the sort of pitch for his team that would require more time and reflection to state. But he feels this IU team, reeling from heartbreak, has what it takes to get back up again and make noise.
“It’s disappointing. Obviously, every loss is disappointing. I think we got a hell of a team. I know a lot of the guys show a lot of grit,” Becker said. “And I know if we get a shot, we’re gonna make a hell of a run.”
For complete coverage of IU football, GO HERE.
The Daily Hoosier –“Where Indiana fans assemble when they’re not at Assembly”
- You can follow us on X: @daily_hoosier and find us on Facebook and Instagram
- Seven ways to support completely free IU coverage at no cost to you




